As told to me by the man it happened to:
Camp Tuscazoar is a rolling 500-acre plot of virgin forest that has been set aside as a preserve by the Boy Scouts of America. Before they came along, however, the camp already had quite a colorful history. The property sits alongside the Tuscarawas River and was home to both trappers and Indians alike in the days of the wild frontier.
Late Fall, 1989, sometime around 9:30pm:
The camp Ranger noticed that one set of hikers had failed to sign out, and their car was still parked in the lot. He got out his flashlight and set off down the trails to find them and bring them back to safety.
Along the way, the flashlight went dead. The Ranger cursed his luck, but being intimately familiar with the entire camp, he decided he would go ahead and keep looking for his missing hikers without it. He knew the camp like the back of his hand, he was quite confident he could navigate the trails in safety.
He reached the trail that lead up to Buzzard's Roost, an overlook that rises about 100 feet above the dam, with a sheer drop to the river below. This is a favorite sightseeing spot for all hikers, and so our brave Ranger navigated his way up the trail to see it they were sitting at the Roost.
He was fairly certain he was nearing the top, but not quite there yet, when he felt a human hand SMACK him in the chest, knocking him to the ground! He put his hands behind him to push himself up... and touched air. He had very nearly fallen the 100 feet off the edge of Buzzard's Roost onto the rocks below at the river's edge...
He shakily got to his feet and went back, only to find his missing hikers in the parking lot, looking equally shaken.
"We were lost, and then this gentleman found us and said he takes care of this place, and he led us back here with an old lantern. When we got to the edge of the forest, the man and the lantern disappeared!" the woman explained.
It is said that a trapper-turned-Indian who went by the nickname of "Icky" lived in the area in the early 1800's, and haunts the trails of Camp Tuscazoar. If you revere the forest and remain respectful during your stay, it's said that Icky will protect you from harm. Our Ranger believes that the ghost of Icky saved his life and brought home his lost hikers that night.
END